The Collaboration Advantage: A Paradigm Shift in Performance Management

January 31, 2024

In the fast-paced world of business, where collaboration is key, top executives recognise the crucial role that an effective performance management system plays in nurturing a high-performing team. However, the traditional approach, often steeped in the constraints of forced ranking and bell curves, has become an obstacle to fostering true collaboration. In this era of innovation and progress, it is imperative for senior leaders to break free from the outdated paradigms that hinder organisational growth and instead embrace a performance assessment model that empowers team leaders to unleash the full potential of their workforce.

The Pitfalls of Traditional Performance Management

In the pursuit of organisational success, the traditional performance management system, with its reliance on forced rankings and bell curves, has inadvertently stifled collaboration and demoralised top performers. Communicating success through labels like “competent” or “average” fails to recognise the nuanced strengths and contributions of individuals. The dated “rank and yank” philosophy, exemplified by Jack Welch’s approach at GE in the 1980s, forced employees into arbitrary categories, sowing seeds of discontent and hampering collaboration within teams. Senior executives must recognise that the journey to excellence cannot be paved by a system that perpetuates mediocrity and pits team members against each other.

Contrary to the belief that stacked ranking identifies high potential, it often overlooks the multifaceted nature of high performers. The focus should shift from rigid categorisation to a more nuanced and insightful evaluation that values collaboration, innovation, and the unique strengths each team member brings to the table. It’s time for executives to liberate their teams from the shackles of outdated performance management practices.

Empowering Leaders for True Collaboration

To truly harness the potential of their teams, senior executives must reconsider the allocation of power in the performance assessment process. The responsibility for evaluating and guiding team members towards success should be firmly placed in the capable hands of team leaders and managers. These leaders, entrusted with strategic decision-making in their roles, deserve the autonomy to assess performance based on a holistic understanding of their team dynamics.

Rather than confining leaders within rigid constraints dictated by historical practices, organisations should empower them with the freedom to exercise sound judgment in evaluating and nurturing talent. By providing leaders with the flexibility to adopt personalised approaches to performance assessment, companies can foster a culture of collaboration and continuous improvement. Executives should champion the shift from a one-size-fits-all approach to a system that celebrates the diversity of talents and encourages leaders to cultivate a high-performing and collaborative environment.

Embracing a New Era of Collaborative Excellence

In the quest for organisational excellence, senior executives must lead the charge in liberating talent from the stifling grip of outdated performance management practices. By dismantling the antiquated forced ranking systems and empowering team leaders, organisations can pave the way for a collaborative and dynamic workplace. It is time to embrace a performance assessment paradigm that reflects the agility required in today’s business landscape, allowing top executives to unlock the true potential of their teams and drive sustained success in the ever-evolving corporate world.


This article explores themes and concepts from content by John O. Burdett.

John O. Burdett is founder of Orxestra® Inc. He has extensive international experience as a senior executive. As a consultant he has worked in more than 40 countries for organisations that are household names. John has worked on organisation culture for some of the world’s largest organisations. His ongoing partnership with TRANSEARCH International means that his thought leading intellectual property, in any one year, supports talent management in many hundreds of organisations around the world. Get in touch with John O. Burdett »

You may also like